All articles · 2026-11-10 · Pension

Pension savings vs. Branch 23 (Tak 23): the difference in return

Same tax advantage, same goal, but a major difference in return. Why a Branch 23 (Tak 23) pension savings insurance can invest fully in equities, while a bank pension savings fund cannot.

By Oskar Knapen, Expert Vermogensopbouw bij Lyff.

Pension savings vs. Branch 23 (Tak 23): the difference in return

Short answer

  • Over five years, Branch 23 pension savings with 100% global equities achieved an annual net return of approximately 11.9%, compared to 4.3% for the top-performing bank pension savings fund.
  • By law, a bank pension savings fund cannot invest fully in equities; a Branch 23 pension savings insurance policy can.
  • The tax advantage remains identical: the same tax reduction of up to 30%, up to the statutory ceiling.
  • With a pension savings fund, the tax authorities calculate the 8% final tax [eindbelasting] on a fictitious return of 4.75% per year, even if the fund yielded less.
  • Past performance is no guarantee of future results; Branch 23 has no capital protection, so your horizon and risk profile remain decisive.

Schedule a meeting

Over five years, Branch 23 pension savings with 100% global equities achieved an annual net return of roughly 11.9%. The strongest traditional pension savings fund at the bank stalled at 4.3%. Same tax advantage, same goal. The difference is structural: a bank pension savings fund is not permitted to invest fully in equities, whereas a Branch 23 pension savings insurance policy is.

The numbers

Annualised net return, using identical timeframes for both. The Branch 23 figures are after policy costs. The pension savings figures are the actual fund returns from the overview of 10/11/2026.

FundProfile2 years3 years5 years10 years
Branch 23 portfolio100% equities12.9%14.7%11.9%n/a
CAPFI Delen (Argenta)dynamic9.2%12.2%4.3%5.5%
KBC Pricosdynamic8.1%10.7%2.8%4.8%
Belfius P. Fd High Equitiesdynamic7.0%10.2%3.2%4.9%
BNP Paribas P. Growthdynamic8.1%10.5%2.7%4.6%

The Branch 23 portfolio consists of three funds: iShares World SRI (50%), M&G European Value (25%), and JPM Global Equities (25%). Over five years, the net return is more than 7 percentage points per year above the best bank pension savings fund. Over a long horizon, that difference in final capital is substantial.

Source for bank funds: Marc Person / mijnportefeuille.be. Past performance offers no guarantee for the future; a Branch 23 investment carries no capital protection.

Why the difference

The statutory equity cap applies to the pension savings fund: the collective fund offered by the bank. Even the "dynamic" variants usually remain below 75% equities; the remainder is allocated to bonds and cash. That puts a brake on returns, especially in strong stock market years.

A Branch 23 pension savings insurance is not a pension savings fund, meaning that cap does not apply. You can include the same global equity funds, but allocated at 100%. The tax advantage remains identical: up to the statutory ceiling, you receive the same tax reduction of up to 30%. For anyone with a long time horizon until retirement, this higher equity weighting is the most important lever, as that difference compounds year after year.

In short: it is not that banks manage their investments poorly. They simply are not allowed to go all-in on equities. An insurance policy does grant that freedom, with the exact same tax advantage.

The fictitious interest rate

It is also worth looking beyond the gross return. With pension savings, the tax authorities collect an 8% final tax [eindbelasting] at age 60, but for a pension savings fund, they do not calculate it on your actual accumulated capital. Instead, they apply a fictitious rate of 4.75% per year to the contributions (contributions made from 1992 onwards), regardless of what the fund actually earned.

That cuts both ways. If the bank fund yields less than that 4.75% net, you pay tax on gains you never received. Over the past five years, bank funds hovered around or well below that mark, at 2.7% to 4.3%. The actual return is disregarded.

In conclusion

Pension savings through the bank and via a Branch 23 policy share the same tax advantage. The difference lies in what your money is allowed to do along the way. At Lyff., we look at what aligns with your situation, time horizon, and risk profile.

Schedule a meeting

Book a meeting with Lyff.